Because the difference between “Can you donate?” and “Will you invest in our community?” changes everything
Picture this common scenario: You’re a first-time school board candidate staring at a blank email screen for twenty minutes. You know you need to send a fundraising appeal to your growing list of supporters, but every sentence you try feels wrong.
“Dear supporters, I need your help…” Delete.
“We’re falling short of our fundraising goals…” Delete.
“Please consider donating to my campaign…” Delete.
Each attempt sounds like every other political fundraising email you’ve ever received—generic, needy, and focused on the candidate’s needs rather than the community’s opportunities. You’re asking people to give you money, but you’re not giving them a compelling reason to care.
Then you try a different approach. Instead of focusing on what you need, you focus on what your supporters want: better communication between the school board and families, more transparency in budget decisions, and genuine parent involvement in education policy.
Your final email begins: “Last week, three different parents told me they felt shut out of decisions affecting their children’s education. You’ve probably felt this frustration too…”
That email raises more money in 24 hours than the previous three appeals combined. Not because you asked for larger amounts, but because you connected funding needs to supporters’ genuine desire for change.
The difference between fundraising appeals that work and those that don’t isn’t about perfect writing or sophisticated design. It’s about understanding that effective appeals don’t ask people to support your campaign—they invite people to invest in their own community’s future.
Why Most Fundraising Appeals Fail (And How Yours Can Succeed)
Before diving into specific techniques, it’s important to understand why so many campaign fundraising messages fall flat:
They focus on the candidate’s needs instead of the community’s opportunities They treat donors as ATMs rather than community partners They rely on guilt or pressure instead of inspiration and empowerment They’re generic and could apply to any candidate in any race They ask for money without clearly connecting donations to meaningful outcomes
Successful appeals flip this script entirely. They position donors as co-creators of positive change, with donations as the tool that makes community improvement possible.
Strategy 1: Lead With Purpose, Not Needs
The Problem with Need-Based Appeals
Most candidates start fundraising appeals by explaining what they need: “We need to raise $5,000 by Friday” or “We’re behind on our fundraising goals.” While urgency can be effective, leading with your campaign’s deficits creates a negative frame that puts donors in the position of solving your problems.
The Power of Purpose-Driven Messaging
Purpose-driven appeals start with the change supporters want to see, then position donations as the means to achieve that change.
Instead of: “We need $2,000 to fund our advertising campaign.” Try: “Families deserve to know where candidates stand on the issues that affect their children’s education. Your contribution helps us ensure every parent in our district receives clear information about our plan for smaller class sizes and better teacher support.”
Instead of: “Help us reach our fundraising goal of $10,000.” Try: “Together, we can build a campaign that gives working families a real voice in city government. Every contribution brings us closer to the grassroots movement our community deserves.”
Practical Application
For each fundraising appeal, start by answering these questions:
- What specific community improvement will this funding support?
- How will donors benefit personally from this change?
- What does success look like for the people you’re trying to help?
- Why is this particular moment important for taking action?
Use these answers to frame your appeal around opportunity and impact rather than campaign logistics and financial targets.
Strategy 2: Tell Stories That Create Emotional Investment
Move Beyond Generic Narratives
Many candidates default to broad, generic stories about why they’re running. While personal motivation matters, the most compelling fundraising stories focus on specific people whose lives would improve if your campaign succeeds.
The Three-Story Formula
Effective campaign storytelling uses a simple structure:
- The Specific Challenge: A real situation that illustrates the problem you’re running to solve
- The Personal Connection: How this challenge affects you, your family, or your community
- The Collaborative Solution: How supporters can help create positive change
Example in Action:
Generic approach: “I’m running because our schools need better funding.”
Story-driven approach: “Mrs. Rodriguez teaches third grade at Lincoln Elementary with 32 students in her classroom. She spends her own money on basic supplies and stays late every day trying to give each child individual attention. I know this story because Mrs. Rodriguez teaches my daughter—and I know she’s not alone. Across our district, dedicated teachers are struggling with impossible conditions. Your $50 contribution helps us fund the community forums where parents and teachers can work together to develop realistic solutions for smaller class sizes and better support for our educators.”
Authenticity Over Perfection
The best fundraising stories feel genuine rather than polished. Share real experiences, admit challenges, and focus on hope rather than despair. Donors respond to authentic emotion more than professional messaging.
Strategy 3: Personalize Based on Supporter Relationship and Interests
Beyond First-Name Personalization
True personalization goes far beyond using someone’s name in the email subject line. It means understanding different supporters’ motivations and tailoring your message accordingly.
Segment Your Supporters
Inner Circle (Family/Close Friends): These appeals can be more personal and direct. Share your genuine feelings about the campaign and ask for specific support levels.
Issue Advocates: Focus on the specific policies or changes that originally attracted their support. Show how donations advance those particular causes.
Community Leaders: Emphasize the broader impact on community leadership and civic engagement. Position donations as investments in democratic participation.
New Supporters: Provide more context about your background and platform. Help them understand how their contribution fits into your overall vision.
Geographic Targeting
Local campaigns often benefit from neighborhood-specific messaging:
- Reference local landmarks or community gathering places
- Mention neighborhood-specific challenges your candidacy addresses
- Share endorsements or support from recognized local figures
- Use data about local voter turnout or community engagement
While platforms like RunTogether can help you organize and coordinate these different appeals, the key is thinking strategically about which messages resonate with which supporters.
Strategy 4: Provide Crystal-Clear Impact Transparency
Specific Dollar Breakdowns
Vague statements about “supporting the campaign” don’t inspire confidence. Donors want to know exactly how their money creates change.
Effective Impact Statements:
$25: Covers the printing and distribution of door hangers for one neighborhood, reaching 150 households with information about our platform $50: Funds one community forum where 30-40 residents can share priorities and ask questions directly $100: Supports targeted digital advertising that reaches 500 local voters with information about early voting dates and locations $250: Covers venue and refreshment costs for a town hall meeting focused on local business development and job creation
Connect Spending to Voter Engagement
The most compelling impact statements connect campaign spending directly to democratic participation and community engagement:
“Your $75 contribution doesn’t just fund campaign materials—it ensures that 200 more neighbors have the information they need to make informed voting decisions.”
“Every $40 donation helps us host conversations where community members can directly influence local policy priorities.”
Strategy 5: Create Urgency Without Manufacturing Crisis
Authentic Deadline Creation
Effective urgency feels genuine rather than manipulative. Base deadlines on real campaign needs and electoral calendar requirements.
Real Urgency Examples:
Filing Deadlines: “We need to submit our campaign finance report by Friday, and we want to show strong grassroots support from our community.”
Event Planning: “The venue deposit for our community forum is due Monday. Can you help us secure this important opportunity for neighborhood dialogue?”
Response Windows: “Early voting starts in two weeks. We have 10 days to reach undecided voters with information about our platform.”
Matching Opportunities: When you have genuine matching fund offers, leverage them strategically rather than creating artificial scarcity.
Momentum-Based Messaging
Sometimes urgency comes from positive momentum rather than external deadlines:
“We’re gaining support faster than expected—help us capitalize on this momentum by reaching even more voters this month.”
“Three neighborhood associations have endorsed our candidacy this week. Let’s build on this energy and expand our outreach to adjacent communities.”
Strategy 6: Build Community Through Collective Action Language
Shift from “My Campaign” to “Our Movement”
Language matters in creating sense of shared ownership and collective purpose.
Individual Focus: “Help my campaign reach voters across the district.” Community Focus: “Together, we can ensure every voter has access to clear information about local candidates and issues.”
Individual Focus: “I need your support to win this election.” Community Focus: “Our community deserves leadership that listens to residents and works collaboratively on solutions.”
Use Inclusive Pronouns and Collective Nouns
We, us, our: Creates partnership rather than hierarchy Together: Emphasizes collaboration and shared effortCommunity, neighbors, families: Connects to shared identity and common interests Movement, coalition, team:Suggests something larger than individual candidacy
Show Growing Support
Help donors understand they’re joining something with momentum:
“You’ll be joining 150 other community members who are already supporting this vision for better local government.”
“Families across five neighborhoods are contributing to this effort to improve communication between city hall and residents.”
Strategy 7: Write Calls-to-Action That Eliminate Friction
Remove Decision-Making Barriers
The most effective calls-to-action make contributing feel easy and obvious.
Weak CTA: “Please consider making a donation to support our campaign.” Strong CTA: “Contribute $35 now to help us reach 300 more voters this week.”
Weak CTA: “Any amount helps our cause.” Strong CTA: “Join 75 other neighbors who’ve already contributed—donate $50 today.”
Multiple Action Options
Not every supporter can donate, but most can contribute something valuable:
“Support our community vision today: • Contribute $25-$100 to fund voter outreach materials • Share this messagewith neighbors who care about local issues
• Volunteer for 2 hours helping with our weekend community forum • Attend our town hall next Thursday to ask questions and show support”
Mobile-Optimized Action
Many supporters will read appeals on their phones and want to act immediately:
- Include direct links to donation pages
- Ensure forms work smoothly on mobile devices
- Offer text-to-give options when possible
- Make social sharing simple with pre-written messages
Strategy 8: Focus on Solutions and Positive Outcomes
Reframe Challenges as Opportunities
Effective appeals acknowledge problems while emphasizing the positive change that’s possible.
Problem-Focused: “Our schools are underfunded and overcrowded.” Solution-Focused: “Together, we can create the educational environment every child in our community deserves.”
Problem-Focused: “City council meetings exclude residents from important decisions.” Solution-Focused: “Your support helps us build the transparent, accessible local government our community has been waiting for.”
Future-Oriented Language
Use language that helps donors envision positive outcomes:
- “Together, we can…”
- “Imagine a community where…”
- “Your contribution helps create…”
- “We’re building toward…”
Celebrate Progress and Momentum
Share positive developments that show donations creating real impact:
“Thanks to supporter contributions, we’ve already hosted three successful community forums with over 200 residents participating. Your continued support helps us expand these conversations to every neighborhood in our district.”
Strategy 9: Express Genuine Gratitude and Ongoing Connection
Immediate Acknowledgment
Every donation should receive prompt, personal recognition:
Automated Confirmations: Professional but warm messages that include tax information and restate the impact of their contribution
Personal Follow-Up: Individual thank-you messages within 24 hours, especially for first-time donors or larger contributions
Handwritten Notes: For major supporters or people whose contributions represent significant personal sacrifice
Ongoing Relationship Building
Transform one-time donors into long-term supporters through consistent, valuable communication:
Impact Updates: Show how previous donations created specific outcomes—”Your contribution last month helped us reach 500 voters at the farmers market”
Exclusive Access: Offer supporters early access to events, behind-the-scenes campaign updates, or direct communication with the candidate
Continued Engagement: Invite donors to volunteer opportunities, policy discussions, or community forums
Recognition Opportunities: With permission, acknowledge supporters in campaign materials, on social media, or at public events
Strategy 10: Test, Learn, and Optimize Your Appeal Strategy
A/B Testing for Local Campaigns
Even small campaigns can benefit from testing different approaches:
Subject Lines: Test emotional appeals vs. factual information vs. urgency-based messaging
Email Length: Compare concise appeals with detailed stories and impact explanations
Call-to-Action Placement: Try CTAs at the beginning, middle, and end of messages
Storytelling Approaches: Test personal stories vs. community-focused narratives vs. policy-oriented content
Tracking What Matters
Monitor metrics that indicate genuine engagement rather than just immediate donations:
Response Rates: What percentage of recipients take some action—donating, sharing, or volunteering?
Repeat Engagement: How many supporters contribute multiple times or attend events after donating?
Social Sharing: Which appeals generate the most organic sharing and word-of-mouth promotion?
Volunteer Conversion: How many donors become active volunteers or community advocates?
Feedback Collection
Regularly survey supporters about their motivations and preferences:
- What originally motivated them to support your candidacy?
- What types of communication do they find most valuable?
- How do they prefer to be thanked and recognized?
- What questions do they have about your platform or campaign strategy?
Use this feedback to refine your approach and strengthen supporter relationships.
The Psychology Behind Effective Local Campaign Appeals
Understanding why people donate to local campaigns helps you craft more effective appeals:
Personal Efficacy: Local donors can see direct results from their contributions. A $50 donation to a city council race has visible impact that the same amount in a federal race doesn’t.
Community Investment: People donate because they live with the consequences of local government decisions. Their contribution improves their own quality of life.
Relationship Trust: Local campaigns are relationship-driven. Donors support candidates they know personally or who come recommended by trusted community members.
Issue Alignment: Supporters contribute when they believe your election will address specific problems they care about—traffic safety, school quality, or economic development.
Democratic Participation: Many local campaign donors are motivated by the opportunity to strengthen democratic engagement and encourage broader community participation.
Effective appeals tap into these motivations authentically, positioning donations as investments in outcomes donors genuinely want.
Your Fundraising Appeals Should Inspire Action, Not Just Request Money
The best local campaign fundraising appeals don’t feel like traditional political solicitations. They feel like invitations to participate in community improvement. They position donors as partners in creating positive change rather than supporters of individual ambition.
When you approach fundraising appeals as opportunities to build community around shared values and common goals, the money becomes secondary to the relationships and momentum you’re creating. Supporters who feel genuinely connected to your vision become advocates who recruit other donors, volunteers who expand your capacity, and long-term allies who support your work whether you win or lose.
Remember: You’re not asking people to fund your campaign—you’re inviting them to invest in the community they want to live in. When your appeals make that opportunity clear, compelling, and easy to act on, fundraising becomes less about asking for money and more about organizing people around hope.
The difference between campaigns that struggle with fundraising and those that thrive often comes down to this fundamental shift in perspective. Donors want to be part of something meaningful. Your job is to show them how their contribution creates the change they’re hoping to see.
Because at the end of the day, the most successful campaigns aren’t funded by people who want to support a candidate—they’re funded by people who want to improve their community and see your candidacy as the vehicle for making that happen.
Ready to organize your supporter outreach and track your fundraising progress? RunTogether helps you coordinate appeals, manage donor relationships, and integrate fundraising with your overall campaign strategy. Get started for free →
Connect with our community: Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn for more campaign tips and success stories from local candidates.
